Appeals From Non-Final and Void Judgments Lead to Triple Dismissal -- Appeals From Even Non-Final Judgments Divest Trial Court of Jurisdiction

One appellant saw three appeals dismissed in a single decision from the Court of Civil Appeals. Busby v. Lewis, Nos. 2060998, 2060999, 2070151 (Ala. Civ. App. May 9, 2008). Two appeals were from nonfinal judgments that had left claims pending against other parties; while a third was from a void judgment entered after the first appeals were lodged — and thus after the trial court had lost jurisdiction of the case.

Continue Reading...

Judgment Which Did Not Address Issue Joined by Parties Was Not Final

A circuit court’s judgment was not final, and would not support an appeal, where the judgment did not address the husband’s request to end his obligation to maintain life insurance for his ex-wife’s benefit. Hennaing v. Hennaing, No. 2060530 (Ala. Civ. App. May 9, 2008). The appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

Continue Reading...

Circuit Court Could Not Reconsider Denied Post-Judgment Motions; Appeal From Later Order Was Untimely

The circuit court lost jurisdiction once it denied an employer’s post-judgment motions under Rules 59 and 60. That denial triggered the 42 days in which the employer had to appeal. The circuit court had no power to reopen, reconsider, and again rule on the employer’s motions. An appeal taken 42 days after that second attempted ruling was dismissed as untimely. Attalla Health Care, Inc. v. Kimble, No. 2061007 (Ala. Civ. App. May 9, 2008).

Continue Reading...

Cases Released May 9, 2008

Rule 59.1 Renders Appeal from Probate Court Untimely

In Morrison v. Phillips, released May 2, 2008, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals dismissed an appeal from a probate court judgment as untimely filed by operation of Rule 59.1.  

Continue Reading...

Motion to Reconsider the Denial of a Post-Judgment Motion a Nullity; Ruling Thereon Will Not Support an Appeal

In N.F.N. and L.C.N. v. J.M.M.J, released on May 2, 2008, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals dismissed an appeal from a judgment awarding custody because the order appealed from purported to rule on a motion to reconsider the denial of a postjudgment motion.  

Continue Reading...

Cases Released May 2, 2008

Alabama Supreme Court clarifies scope of post-judgment discovery in connection with review of punitive damages

In Ex parte Vulcan Materials, [Ms. 1051184] (Ala. April 25, 2008) , the Alabama Supreme Court clarified the allowable scope of post judgment discovery in connection with a review of punitive damages, including the scope of discovery regarding a defendant's financial position.  The decision also includes interesting concurrences by Justice Murdock and Chief Justice Cobb.  

Continue Reading...

"Alabama Supreme Court releases data: Fewer cases, decisions take longer"

The Birmingham News has an interesting article about recent statistics on the caseload at the Alabama Supreme Court.  Click the link for the article entitled  "Alabama Supreme Court releases data: Fewer cases, decisions take longer."

Tags:

Cases Released on April 25, 2008